Jesse,
I may be partial here since I own the 2005 191F/S but from my skewed standpoint I would agree that the 191 is probably the better choice. If your not that into fishing it is a great boat, with room for plenty and it's very comfortable. I have a 14 year old son and we fish, tube and ski with mine all with my wife comfortably riding in the front or next to me. Just hard to beat this boat in my opinion. Oh and when you do get into fishing (how could you not
) just leave the bow cushions at home, move the seats around, put down the back seats and it becomes a fishing machine capable of handling just about anything. ENJOY